J Street, The pro-peace/pro-Israel/pro-Palestine Jewish lobby just released a monster of a poll on American Jewish political attitudes. The takeaway: we're liberal as hell; we hate Bush; we know Bush has been a disaster for Israel; we'll support any peace deal the Israelis make; and the only thing we're uncomfortable with to that end is giving East Jerusalem back to the Palestinians.
Let's go down the line. Seventy-four percent of us view Bush unfavorably and 83 percent of us disapprove of his job performance. While 76 percent of the country as a whole says the U.S. is on the wrong track, an astonishing 90 percent of American Jews say the same. Only 21 percent of us approve of the Iraq war and only 29 percent think Bush is good for Israel, and those are clearly the shmucks that kissed ass in Hebrew school and snitched when the rest of us used the synagogue phone booth and cloakroom to make out or get high.
When asked if the U.S. should or shouldn't actively broker Mideast peace, it broke down 55 percent for U.S. involvement and 30 percent against. J Street, the menschen, took that a step further and examined support for the hard choices piece requires. "Even if it meant the United States publicly stating its disagreements with both the Israelis and the Arabs?" Yes -- 75 percent; no -- 25 percent. "Even if it meant the United States exerting pressure on both Israelis and Arabs to make the compromises necessary for peace?" Yes -- 70 percent; no -- 30 percent.
In terms of negotiating positions for an Arab-Israeli settlement, 59 percent agree that Israel will need to "withdraw from most of the West Bank and dismantle many of the Israeli settlements." Another 58 percent agree that for full peace with Syria -- and an abandonment of their support for Hamas and Hezbollah -- Israel should get out of the Golan. Only 44 percent, though, endorse the statement that Palestinian East Jerusalem should be part of the state of Palestine. And while that's the only non-majority position among American Jews for what can fairly be called the dovish line, 44 percent is still a substantial amount of support.
J Street's poll supports its contention that the attitudes of most of us are far, far out of whack with what this country's self-appointed Jewish leaders -- the Joe Liebermans, the AIPACs, the Sheldon Adelsons, the Commentary magazines -- say we're about and what we're actually about.
Shma YisroelBy: Spencer Ackerman Wednesday July 16, 2008 12:18 pm |
3 Responses to “Shma Yisroel”
You must be logged in to post a comment. If you don't have an account, then please feel free to register for one.
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight


Support this site!
Keep
up with news
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About ATTACKERMAN
Advanced search
RSS/XML Feed
Very interesting survey. The willingness to strongly oppose Hagee was really beautiful, especially when they were told that the leading Reform rabbi denounced him. This means that they would take the leading Reform rabbi seriously *g*
Other interesting points: 31% call themselves “liberal”, and more discuss Israel with family and friends more frequently than they go to synagogue.
Although the most liberal positions got 70% to agree there is a lot of ambivalence: a lot of agreeing not very strongly. Even the most hard-line position got 48% to agree in part.
The questions were worded, “Israel will do” in exchange for peace. So perhaps the current Israeli leadership will choose these things although they don’t need to and they may not be around much longer.
Very nice that Jews view Obama more favorably and are more likely to vote for him than the general white population surveyed by the NYT today. Obama’s favorability rating was the same as the Democratic Party’s in general and greater than Pelosi’s.
“• Throughout the survey, there is a definite pattern of attitudes broken down by denomination. Reform and unaffiliated Jews are the most supportive of peace efforts and American engagement, followed by Conservative Jews who generally provide majority support – though less than among Reform and unaffiliated Jews – on the numerous measures in the survey. Orthodox Jews express very different, and considerably more hawkish, views on nearly every question from Iraq and Iran to American engagement and the various compromises being considered in Arab-Israeli negotiations.”
Surprise!
Perhaps rotating those Congressional statement questions might have gotten a different result, and maybe they actually did that.