Reflecting on today's New York Times story about how Hezbollah's youth corps are part of a planned holistic "society of resistence" built by the Shiite Lebanese militant group, Andrew "Abu Muqawama" Exum has a really profound insight:
My worry is that the greatest danger in creating a society of resistance is that you might actually succeed. [Boston University professor Andrew] Bacevich may talk about American militarism, but I worry more about these non-state actors who build up armed conflict as their raison d'être. If peace in suddenly in your best interest a year or so down the road, for example, how are you going to tell these kids to stand down? Are they going to be happy working in a cell phone kiosk in Tyre?
That's exactly right. The cynic will want to say that organizations like Hezbollah have no intention of standing down, and the society-of-resistance crap represents a fairly thorough strategy. My guess is kind of a modified view of that: they're building the equivalent of an ideological perpetual-motion-machine, where their raison d'etre might be the realization of specific, not metaphysical, goals like gaining control of Lebanon or the reconquest of Israel or what-have-you, but their ethic or espirit d'corps is based around being implacable. Call it a condition of permanent hysteria. Maybe it's the case that in Year X their best interests are to make peace. But they're creating a mindset where they'll never perceive peace as being in their interests in any long-term sense.
And, to paraphrase Chris Hedges, a culture of resistence is a force that gives us meaning. To return to a bourgeoise life, or to choose one -- selling cellphones in Tyre, for instance -- is meant, I'd submit, to be a foreclosed option. The building of the society of resistence, says the recruiter to the youth-scout-in-training -- now that is the honorable profession. There's time enough to sell cell phones in paradise. It's almost as if these guys are bad people or something.
Crossposted to The Streak.
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight


Support this site!
Keep
up with news
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About ATTACKERMAN
Advanced search
RSS/XML Feed
Exum’s worry is misplaced. Who’s going to tell these kids that it’s time for peace? If you train them that Israel and America are implacable enemies, then peace won’t be coming in their lifetimes.
Their leaders will be describing any cessation of armed struggle as temporary, and diplomacy will be defined as war by other means.
I always worried about what would become of those guys in the Boston Tea Party. And I fretted that the men/women who lined up on a field in Concord were starting bad habits, not to mention the two rowdies who were shot in April 1775, next to my now current barber shop along Mass. Ave, Cambrige, as the British retreated back to Boston. Once you start something like that, you never know how it will end.
nice one, scarecrow.
On the other hand, it does explain why conservatism failed — it lost its will to fight after becoming a majority, couldn’t sustain that edge acquired from resisting progress for so long. It should be a lesson to the left side of the aisle that the spirit of resistance must be nurtured and that it can collapse after it achieves its ends.