How did I not see until just now that Tom Ricks, the best defense reporter in America, has launched a blog at Foreign Policy’s website? Check out what he found in a just-released Army War College report:
"HAMAS’ political and strategic development has been both ignored and misreported in Israeli and Western sources which villainize the group, much as the PLO was once characterized as an anti-Semitic terrorist group," writes Sherifa Zuhur, a research professor at the War College’s Strategic Studies Institute. "Negotiating solely with the weaker Palestinian party-Fatah-cannot deliver the security Israel requires. . . . The underlying strategies of Israel and HAMAS appear mutually exclusive . . . . Yet each side is still capable of revising its desired endstate and of necessary concessions to establish and preserve a long-term truce, or even a longer-term peace."
Abu Muqawama — who, just as I predicted, is as retired from blogging as Jay-Z is from rapping — says Ricks will put him out of business. That hits really close to home. I’ll never be as judicious or knowledgeable as Tom, but I am vastly more profane. Please don’t stop reading this blog.
Update: Foreign Policy is turning into a for-pol blogger murderers’ row. Calderone reports that in addition to Ricks and Marc Lynch, they’re bringing on Stephen "Israel Lobby" Walt, Dan Drezner, Laura Rozen, David Rothkopf, a group blog called Madame Secretary and a conservative for-pol group blog called Shadow Government.
That latter group blog is a good idea in theory. You should want a smart critique from the loyal opposition, and Phil Zelikow and Peter Feaver are certainly qualified. The trouble with policymaker or potential-policymaker blogs is that no one wants to say anything that could create a stumbling block at a far-off Senate confirmation hearing. That’s one of the reasons why TPMCafe’s old America Abroad group blog of Very Serious People failed. You’d have a slaughter one day in Iraq, total policy lassitude in Afghanistan, and if you went over to America Abroad you’d see the page topped by a week-old Lee Feinstein post about Japan or something. Hopefully Shadow Government won’t be similarly anodyne or anti-rigorous, but experience points to inherent difficulties with this.
Login Here




4 Comments
Spotlight


Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About ATTACKERMAN
Advanced search
RSS/XML Feed
Outstanding! Part of the reason I stick by the NYT is the opportunity cost of getting foreign news from other places.
IMHO there is more there, there in that Army War College report. I posted about it at my little spot but I hope others actually go and read the full snyopsis if not the whole report. It is an anathema to everything we are hearing from leaders on both sides of the aisle everyday on Tee Vee about the current conflict.
From his front page…
That I did not see coming.
Well, time for me to apply to law school then.