Earlier today I wrote that Dennis Ross was finally getting made an Obama administration "envoy" to… uh… a country with a name that rhymes with Gee-Wham. (Or, if you’re fancy, Gee-RAHM.) Not so, says acting State Department spokesman Robert Wood! But what will his job actually be, then? Hard to say. You really have to read the full transcript from today’s State press briefing for the full measure of insanity over State’s unwillingness to explain what Ross will be doing.
Let me be clear, he’s not an envoy. He will not be negotiating. He’ll be working on regional issues. He will not be – in terms of negotiating, will not be involved in the peace process. But again, he is going to be advising the Secretary on long-term strategic issues across the region.
Wood doesn’t even want to tell reporters which countries fall under the portfolio of the Special Advisor to the Secretary of State for The Gulf and Southwest Asia. ("I just – I don’t have the list to run off – you know, right off the top of my head here.") While Ross won’t be negotiating, he will "meet with the leaders in the region" — only Wood won’t say what the region entails and when asked, Wood said:
Look, it’s more – he’s going to be providing advice to the Secretary on a number of regional issues, and I would not try to limit Dennis’s advice to, you know, just those regions. He may have other – you know, he may have advice that he wants to give the Secretary on other issues. I don’t think we’re trying to narrow it here.
In other words, Dennis Ross is everywhere and nowhere, the Keyser Soze of the State Department. You could read the transcript and conclude that Ross is all-powerful, advising Secretary Hillary Rodham Clinton — who basically ended a photo op today when a reporter asked about Ross — on all manner of issues. Or you could read it and conclude that Ross met a welter of bureaucratic resistance at the State Department to the prospect of him getting an envoyship, and Clinton required a face-saving way of shunting him aside. My very-helpful guess is that Ross’s role remains unsettled, at least until he and Richard Holbrooke meet in the Octagon.
Crossposted to The Streak.



38 Comments
Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About ATTACKERMAN
RSS/XML Feed
I don’t get it. Why is Ross persona nongrata? He’s a DC insider, right?
So? He doesn’t have superpowers. Plus it would appear that Richard Holbrooke, who has more wasta than Ross, has boxed him out.
wasta=clout?
Steve Clemons over at Washington Note had a few things to say about Ross’s new position
http://www.thewashingtonnote.c….._ross_get/
I wonder how much an unnamed, undefined, State Department job pays?
Inside baseball is Clemons stock & trade. I wonder how much of it he makes up out of thin air.
ouch. that’s gonna leave a mark. I remember getting a lot more responsibility and a new title during my old life. I quickly received an email from my supervisor to inform me it wasn’t a promotion. Uh, thank you?
Hey! Maybe they should have a winner-takes-all cage match on pay per view between Holbrooke and Ross.
Did similar thing with Steve Rattner as auto czar situation, brought in someone who knew what they were doing (Ron Bloom) which stole the headlines and then quietly made Rattner his boss.
Spencer, could the hesitancy on naming specific countries also have to do with India and Pakistan? I recall listening to an NPR story a couple of weeks ago, where the reporter was talking about US-India-Pakistan relations following the investigation into the Mumbai bombing. The conversation spilled into the staffing of the new Obama administration, and India was really pushing to limit a certain regional appointment to Pakistan and NOT include India. “Pakistan needs to be dealt with as a part of the Afghan/Pakistan border issues in the war on terror, and that doesn’t include us in India,” was the viewpoint the reporter related from his sources in India. He went on to say that from India’s standpoint, this also would make the US-India relationship more direct, thus allowing India to view itself as an equal partner to the US and not half of an India/Pakistan deal. Kind of boost the Indian vision of themselves as a growing world power in their own right.
Any thoughts/reaction on your end, Spencer?
(Sorry I can’t find a link to the story I heard . . . have to keep looking.)
Not much. Over at New America foundation on the MSM he seems to be gaining quite the reputation. Some of the best I/P conflict conversations at that site
Can you imagine when Dennis Ross was mentioned as an envoy to Iran what this said to Iran? This is a man who supported a pre-emptive attack on Iran
Iran: Talk Tough With Tehran
By Dennis Ross | NEWSWEEK
Published Nov 29, 2008
“It’s not too late to stop Iran from getting the bomb. Tehran clearly wants
nukes for both defensive and offensive purposes. But it’s not clear the Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, would sacrifice anything to get nuclear weapons. In fact, history shows that his government responds to outside pressure, restricting its actions when it feels threatened and taking advantage when it judges it can.”
For Middle East Peace, Dennis Ross is Not the Change We Seek
“He’s never been fair with the Palestinians so bringing him back into the fold would be counter-productive. Obama has to bring in new faces.”
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/…..43888.html
Well, I have yet to meet a foreign policy expert I admire, so if they all admire him, then … (Juan Cole on ME is my exception.)
Clemons is less extreme, with a scintilla more common sense than some, but that’s not saying much.
Iran: Talk Tough With Tehran
http://www.newsweek.com/id/171256
with you on Juan Cole
He’ll be here on his forthcoming book in March, 4 days after his book is published.
Could be just a matter of keeping Dennis “The Menace” Ross inside the tent pissing out rather than outside the tent pissing in.
I’ll bet Scooter Libby could find out!
he’s a real nowhere man
Know where?
No. Where?!
AKA Israel’s stenographer.
Joining all the others in a very big steno pool. *g*
Barney Frank just used a new technical term for toxic assets: whoop-de-dos.
Yes, Ross is the boss! Obama is subject to his every whim and Ross will be having Obamadoing AIPACs bidding.
Will it be days or weeks before our nuclear warheads start falling on Iran?
Ian has a new post —>
I gather Ross is more adept than his peers.
i don’t like the implications of the term “peace process” if we’re referring to I-RAN .. no state of hostilities exist between iran and the U.S… why do we have to “make peace” when we are at peace ..
fuck this neocon bullshit …
Probably makes more typos, but apparently has an endless supply of WhiteOut.
Sorry for the pre-computer age typewriter reference which leave Twitters scratching their Blackberries in confusion.
The peace process is meant to refer to I/P. They were trying to make clear that Ross’ mission is in no way part of that and therefore specifally meant that Iran and “peace process” are different.
better?
Makes sense
A person who knows the former or current players, who has worked on the problems at hand, is better off working “without portfolio”. I’ve been hoping the administration would find a way to bring Ross back, and having him not be an “envoy” is icing on the cake. He’s “deniable”, he can try all sorts of crazy crap, and some of it might work. Admittedly, it’s not so great for Ross himself, anything that works gets credited to others. I think it says a lot about the man for taking on the job under these circumstances.
thanks for the heads up Juan’s words have been showing up all over the place…even in the MSM
Here is an interesting article about Dennis Ross
WASHINGTON, Jan. 29 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ — Former Clinton Administration
Middle East diplomat Dennis Ross is under consideration as US State Department
envoy to Iran. Ross is currently the chairman of the Jewish People Policy
Planning Institute (JPPPI) in Jerusalem, established by the Jewish Agency in
2002. Ross could face legal challenges under the 1938 Foreign Agents
Registration Act, or FARA, if he enters US government service.
FARA protects the American people and Congress from stealth propaganda and
foreign lobbying through strict public disclosure filings. The Jewish Agency
has repeatedly surfaced during investigations in the US. In the 1960s the
Senate Foreign Relations Committee uncovered a network of stealth Jewish
Agency “conduits” financing grassroots Israel lobby startup groups through the
American Zionist Council (AZC). During 1963 hearings the Senate revealed the
equivalent of $35 million went toward US lobbying, including $38,000 to
American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) founder Isaiah Kenen between
1960-1961.
http://www.reuters.com/article…..RN20090129
That would be more than 1% of their budget and less then 50 years ago.
And Dennis Ross would almost have been a teenager.
Ross is a hawk; putting him in charge of anything real would provoke confrontation with Iran (and would help Ahmadinijad politically).
Ross is being put in charge of conveying thoughts and words to representatives of Iran.
Are you worried that he is going to speak harshly when his mission is to solicit dialogue?
” For months many concerns have been raised over the prospect of a Ross appointment as a special envoy to or an adviser on Iran. To assign the former diplomat who actively supports not only coercive actions against Iran, but the policy option of a preventive military attack seems counterintuitive to the need for trust in this highly sensitive relationship.
In 2007 and 2008 Dennis Ross, working on the Presidential Task Force for the Washington Institute for Near East Policy (WINEP), convened the report “How to Deepen the U.S.-Israel Cooperation on the Iranian Nuclear Challenge.” “
http://www.opednews.com/articl…..4-654.html
Who is Cheryl Biren-Wright and what does quoting her views add?