My friend Alyssa Rosenberg wondered the other day why there aren’t more movies about journalism, which from my perspective is like asking why there aren’t more movies about accounting. Matthew Yglesias, in responding, dragged me into this:
I think the issue here is just that not enough happens in journalism. I’ve watched Spencer Ackerman report out some pretty good stories. It involved a certain amount of looking stuff up online, a great deal of waiting for people to return phone calls, some taking notes, some talking. And then you kind of need to do it all over again. Filling out FOIA requests is important, but watching someone do it would be deadly dull.
Alyssa replies here and I have no stake in the argument. But I will say this. If you were to make a movie of my workday today, it would center around my acquisition of some intriguing-but-incomplete information about something important, followed by my utter failure at confirming it. The drama in that scene would pivot to a certain phone call in which I laid out relevant portions of the aforementioned information to an individual involved in this particular affair, only to be told there would be no reply and I shouldn’t read anything into that non-reply one way or another. Then I would longingly eye the bottle of Excedrin I keep next to my phone.
Scene two would feature an internal monologue about whether I should say fuck it and just put the shit out there, caveated as single-sourced and anonymously-sourced information, especially when imagining my inevitable heartburn if/when a competitor reports the stuff out there. The monologue would end with me deciding there’s just no responsible way of doing that, even if competitors of mine decide otherwise. The scene would give way to an interminable coda of regret, recrimination and second-guesswork. Possibly suitable for either the director’s cut or the deleted scenes.
No one in his or her right mind would want to watch this movie, and it’s not particularly pleasant to act in, either.
Login Here




8 Comments
Spotlight


Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About ATTACKERMAN
Advanced search
RSS/XML Feed
I think what Yglesias describes could be turned into a compelling Fugazi video.
I think that at some point everyone thinks their job (and life) is interesting enough to be made into a movie. In general, it isn’t. Even Hollywood thinks their job is so exciting that it should be the basis of countless TV shows and films. And in general it shouldn’t be either.
Spencer, deep breath.
We can both agree that you could make a very nice, uncomplicated living writing web copy, white papers and training video scripts. Considered and rejected.
You do what you do because it’s what you do, not because it has any glamor or likelihood of vast riches.
I stomped around the globe doing what I did because the alternative was soul-crushing, and now I’m old and paying the price in physical and mental health and know what?
I still can’t understand why someone would do anything else…
mikey
Gotta find a tall guy, a smoker, to meet in parking garages. Then it becomes a great movie. Especially if your editor gives this source a cool name, that is more than slightly prurient. Also, Redford.
imo “All The President’s Men” led to a rise in I-can-be-a-star journalists.
I have already noted this at Yglesias’s place, but if you think your day is boring, trying working in a laboratory for a day. MMM DNA fingerprinting almost as exiting as brushing your teeth 300 times in a row — without a pause. Yet somehow CSI, CSI Miami, CSI New York and CSI New Rochelle are still on the air (well on the airlessness of space via SKY-TV anyway).
Just have some jump cuts, classic rock and pointless zooming as you stare at your monitor agonizing about whether to hit the post button.
Call it something like “comment section instigation” DC.
Movies about accountants can be pretty hilarious, my dear Bloom.
Point well taken, but that wasn’t about accounting.
@robert.waldmann, I hear you. We might be able to make a good sitcom about a blogospheric journalist who solves crimes and capers from the comfort of the Big Bear Cafe. Hi-jinks ensue.