So here’s a summary — like nine minutes of it — of what I think I’ve gotten wrong about Iraq over the years, and why. In retrospect, I don’t do enough to address the why, and if you don’t think it’s too navelgaze-y, I’ll elaborate in the coming days.
What I Got Wrong About The Iraq War |
|
| By: Spencer Ackerman Thursday July 23, 2009 2:33 pm | |
When Bloggingheads asked Eli Lake and me to film a diavlog yesterday, I figured that Maliki’s visit to Washington provided a good opportunity to talk about Iraq, something I resolved yesterday morning to once again cover in depth. Eli and I talked it over and decided that we should each discuss what we got wrong about Iraq and why we got it wrong. I give this more thought than my blogging indicates. My friend Megan McArdle occasionally runs a feature where she reflects on intellectual mistakes she made, and I have a lot of respect for such self-reflection. In a business that never punishes intellectual mistakes and often creates active disincentives to remedying ignorance — when was the last time you saw someone admit on a cable news show that s/he doesn’t know something? — it’s important we hold ourselves to high standards.



1 Comment
Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About ATTACKERMAN
RSS/XML Feed
No sack cloth and ashes for this dynamic duo. Not a surprise.
Spencer makes mea culpas about his doubts concerning the surge. Wow. No discussion about how the Iraq war was the biggest foreign policy disaster in our nation’s history. Yes, this war is more disatrous than ‘Nam due to the ME being a very important region and SE Asia being a backwater.
But this Lake douche takes the cake. He regrets that he did not understand that the all volunteer military could not withstand a long term occupation of a hostile country. His other regret being that he should have investigated more fully whether our military planners invaded with a force sufficient to complete the job.
If this asshole listened to General Shinseki, he would have had his question answered. But Shinsecki made Wolfowitz squirm and then was purged.
The question I’d like answered is why you both supported the war? Did Saddam Hussein’s support of suicide bombers in Israel affect your judgement? Obviously Israel is an important subject for Lake, did he support the war so that an enemy of Israel was destroyed?
The “Best and Brightest” WASPs gave us Vietnam. The neocons and their liberal interventionist friends brought us Iraq.
McNamara was shamed publicly until he wrote his book apologizing for his sins.
When will Eli Lake apologize. How about Wolfowitz, David Wurmser, Doug Feith, Frank Gaffney, Elliot Abrams, Jeffrey Goldberg? Walt and Mearsheimer noted that friends of Israel made this war possible. This topic is still taboo but this discussion must be had if we are to avoid a war with Iran that Dennis Ross (and Eli Lake) actively seeks.
At least the WASPs were ashamed. No such luck with our new elite.