For an officer rising through the ranks, the right experiences are critical. A Marine friend of mine faced a situation a few years ago in which a phenomenal opportunity lay right in front of him, but he felt pressured not to accept it. He had an offer to work directly for General Petraeus–but he knew that his current commander would see the job as veering off the standard career track, and would deny the transfer. So he had to wait for the commander to rotate out of his unit before accepting the job.
To someone outside the military, a chance to work for General Petraeus in 2005 might not seem ”off track” at all–it would seem undeniably valuable to serve so close to the officer then in charge of training and equipping all Iraqi forces. To military service members, however, this would need no explanation. Military personnel are accustomed to a system in which young officers are dependent on their commanders to recognize the value of alternative experiences, and they wouldn’t be surprised that a young Marine officer who wanted to cross service lines to work for an Army general would expect serious resistance. That friend, a much decorated and respected Marine, has since left the Corps and is now at graduate school with me.
I’m kicking myself for not writing this first. Anyone who’s spent the time reporting on young and midcareer officers has heard endless permutations on that theme. For booklength explorations, I recommend The Fourth Star.



1 Comment
Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About ATTACKERMAN
RSS/XML Feed
The dominant types of military commander you are going to have are either: 1) S/He’ll want to make sure he ‘takes care of everyone’ and ensures your career boxes are checked, or 2) S/He’ll assign people to the jobs that maximize the short-term effectiveness of the unit with no regard whatsoever to your career or desires.
The personnel guys manage you like you’re a code. They’ll flex for personal circumstances, but what your spouse wants seems to matter more than what you want. If they can’t slot you into a job you would like because you have the wrong specialty or whatnot, you’d better call in some favors. Unless, of course, you’re too junior but they can’t fill the billet with anyone senior. Then they can bend the rules.
I wish I could reset the clock, but I can’t. So it’s over.